Sateesh T S vs. State Of Karnataka

Original PDF →
CRL.P/11050/2022HC KarnatakaGSTCNR KAHC01048646202202 July 2024Bench: M.NAGAPRASANNA12 pages
For Petitioner: SRI. DILIP KUMAR I S., ADVOCATEFor Respondent: SRI. P. THEJESH, HCGP FOR R1; SMT. TEJASWINI RAJKUMAR ., ADVOCATE FOR R2

No AI summary yet for this judgment.

Cause title — parties, addresses and appearances
- 1 - NC: 2024:KHC:24804 CRL.P No. 11050 of 2022 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 2ND DAY OF JULY, 2024 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 11050 OF 2022 BETWEEN: SATEESH T S S/O SRI RANGACHAR AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS DIRECTOR, HOYSALA PROJECTS PVT LTD NO.104, GROUND FLOOR INFANTRY TECHNO PARK INFANTRY ROAD BANGALORE-560 001. …PETITIONER (BY SRI. DILIP KUMAR I S.,ADVOCATE) AND: 1. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY COMMERCIAL STREET POLICE REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA BANGALORE-560 009. 2. SRI P. NANDA KISHORE S/O Y K PUTTASWAMEGOWDA AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS R/A NO.107, 6TH MAIN INDIRANAGAR BANGALORE-560 038. …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. P. THEJESH, HCGP FOR R1; SMT. TEJASWINI RAJKUMAR .,ADVOCATE FOR R2) Digitally signed by NAGAVENI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - NC: 2024:KHC:24804 CRL.P No. 11050 of 2022 THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482 CR.P.C BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONERS PRAYING THAT THIS HONBLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO QUASH ENTIRE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN C.C.NO.27982/2022 AGAINST THE PETITIONER FILED FOR THE OFFENCE P/U/S 406,420 OF IPC PENDING ON THE FILE OF THE 4TH A.C.M.M., BENGALURU AS THE CONTINUATION PROCEEDINGS IS CLEAR ABUSE OF PROCESS OF LAW. THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

ORDER

The petitioner is before this Court calling in question the proceedings in C.C.No.27982/2022, pending on the file of the IV Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bengaluru.

2.

During the pendency of this petition, the parties to the lis have settled the dispute amongst themselves and drawn up a memorandum of settlement. The settlement insofar as it germane to the present lis, reads as follows: MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING THIS MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING IS ENTERED ON THIS 12th DAY OF JANUARY, 2024 BY AND BETWEEN

1.

Smt. Lalitha Gowda W/o Y.K.Puttasome Gowda, NC: 2024:KHC:24804 Aged about 79 years, Residing at No.307, 6th Main, Indiranagar, Bangalore-560 038. 2. Sri.P.Nanda Kishore, S/o Y.K.Puttasome Gowda, Aged about 52 years, Residing at No.307, 6th Main, Indiranagar, Bangalore-560 038. Hereinafter (Which expression shall wherever the context so admits or requires mean and include his successors and legal representatives executors, administrators and assignees) called as FIRST PARTY.

AND M/S. Hoysala Projects Pvt ltd, Represented by its Managing director, Sri.T.S. Sateesh, Having its office at No.104, ground Floor Infantry Techno Park, Infantry Road, Opp. Gem Palaza, Bangalore-560 001. Hereinafter (Which expression shall wherever the context so admits or requires mean and include its successors and legal representatives' executors, administrators and assignees) called as SECOND PARTY.

1.

WHEREAS the first Party and the SECOND PARTY, being joint owners of all that piece and parcel of Sy no.65/2A, measuring 1 acre and Sy no.66/1 measuring 0-30 1/2 guntas respectively (76,774.5 Sq Mts), situated in Byatarayanapura Village, Yelahanka Hobli, Bangalore North taluk, old BBMP kahta no.347/65/2A, 66/1 which is more fully NC: 2024:KHC:24804 described herein as SCHEDULE A PROPRETY and have entered into Joint development Agreement with the second party herein, dated 29/07/2013 vide document no.ΒΥΡ-1- 03528/2013-14, stored in C.D. No.BYPD184, in the office of the Sub-registrar, Byatarayanapura, Bangalore and have also executed a registered General Power of Attorney, dated 29/07/2013, vide document bearing no.BYP-4-00098-2013-14, stored in CD no.BYPD184, in the office of the Sub- registrar. Byatarayanapura, Bangalore, to develop the Schedule A property which is more fully described herein.

2.

WHEREAS, in terms of the Joint Development Agreement and GPA executed by the first party along with the other Owners, and the Developer second party herein has amalgamated the Khata of the schedule 'A' Property with the adjacent property, wherein 'Hoysala ACE is being constructed and the BBMP has issued new amalgamated Khata No.347/65/2A, 66/1 & 65/1 and the Developer has formulated a scheme for development of the Schedule 'A' Property into a residential apartment complex known as "HOYSALA ACE- II" consisting of basement, ground and Sixteen) upper floors, common compound, entrances, lobbies, stairs, lifts and passages with rights in the common areas of the residential apartment complex.

3.

WHEREAS, in view to develop the Schedule 'A' Property, the Developer being the power of attorney holder of the owners have applied for revised amalgamated plan sanction to the Bruhath Bangalore Mahanagara Palike for construction of Basement, Ground and 16 upper floors and accordingly the BBMP has sanctioned plan, vide JDTP(N)/LP/173/2010- 11, dated 28.05.2014 for construction of NC: 2024:KHC:24804 residential apartment over the Schedule 'A' Property.

4.

WHEREAS the first Party along with the other joint owners of the schedule A property and the SECOND PARTY, have entered into a Supplementary Sharing Agreement, dated 26/07/2014. In the said Supplementary Sharing Agreement It was agreed between the first and second party that the first party would be allotted with the flats as per the Schedule 'C' and D' of the Supplementary Sharing Agreement and that the second party would be allotted with the flats falling under the Schedule I'. The said schedule C and D property of the Supplementary Sharing Agreement is reiterated herein as annexures to this memorandum of understanding. It was further mutually agreed between the parties that by virtue of allotment made in the supplementary sharing agreement, the parties are entitled to own, possess and enjoy their respective shares as the full and absolute owners with full powers of enjoyment and alienation and shall be entitled to sell, to create charge to let out for rent and to deal with the same in any manner.

WHEREAS the first party along with the other joint owners had entered into a Memorandum of understanding with the second party dated 06/08/2014, wherein the parties had agreed that the Second Party would provide access to the Schedule 'A' property in the Schedule 'B' property of the Memorandum of understanding dated 06/08/2014 and has permitted the Parties of the NC: 2024:KHC:24804 First Part along with other joint owners to amalgamate the Schedule A' property with the Schedule B' Property and to get the revised combined plan sanction for constructing residential apartment complex in the Schedule 'A' Property. It was further agreed therein that the consideration of the Second Party agreeing to provide access to the Schedule 'A' Property in the Schedule B' Property and allowing the Parties of the First Part along with the other owners to amalgamate the Schedule 'A' property with the Schedule B properties of the First Part have jointly agreed to allot/transfer Super built up area of 4563 Sq.Ft in the apartment building to be constructed on the Schedule 'A' Property and proportionate undivided share schedule 'A' property in favour of the Second Party. It was further agreed that the Parties of the First Part along with the other owners have jointly authorized the Developer herein to deduct a super built up area of 4563 Sq. Ft i.e. 507 Sq.Ft each from the share of the Parties in first part along with the other owners. It was further agreed that the Parties of the First Part along with the other owners and the Developer have agreed to execute and register a sale deeds favour of the Second Party in respect of the Flats amounting to a super build up area of 4563 Sq. Ft together with proportionate undivided share and agreed to do, execute and perform all other acts, deeds and things as may be necessary at the cost of the Second Party for effectively conveying the title of the Flats to the Second Party, on completion of the Project. That on execution and registration of sale deed as aforesaid, the Second Party shall peacefully and quietly possess and enjoy the Flats without any let, hindrance or interruption or disturbance by the NC: 2024:KHC:24804 Parties of the First Part or Developer or any persons claiming through or under them.

WHEREAS it was agreed between the parties that on completion of the project, the first party would receive the flats mentioned in the Annexure titled as Schedule C and D, despite this being a covenant in the Supplementary sharing agreement the first party approached the commercial street police and filed a complaint against the second party, which resulted in registration of FIR in crime no.111/2021, subsequently charge-sheeted for the offences punishable under section 406,420 of Indian Penal Code(IPC) in CC.NO.27982/2022 pending on the files of 4 Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bangalore. The second party has approached the hon'ble high court of Karnataka in Crl.P.NO.11050/2022, for quashing of criminal proceedings in CC.NO.27982/2022. This being the case both the parties have decided to amicably settle their difference hence this memorandum of understanding is being drawn.

THIS MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING IS WITNESSETH AS FOLLOWS:

a. It is agreed by the both the parties to resolve the issues mutually by obliging to the terms mentioned herein.

b. A Total of 14 Car Parks will be allotted to the first Party and the details is mentioned below

Car Park Number-87 Car Park Number - 92 Single Car Park Number - 93 Car Park Number - 83-

Car Park Number-089 A&B Back To Back

Car Park Number 088 A&B Back To Back NC: 2024:KHC:24804 Car Park Number 82 A&B Back To Back

Car Park Number-84 Car Park Number -85 Single Car Park Number - 90 Car Park Number - 91

c. The Security Deposit for all the above-mentioned flats (F301, F502, F504, F1304, F1501, F101, F103, F1201 and F1602) will be waived off against Good Will amount.

d. In lieu of the settlement arrived at it is resolved that considering the amount paid by the second party to the first party i.e., to Lalitha Gowda as refundable and non-refundable deposit to the tune of Rs. 10,00,000/-(Rupees Ten Lakhs Only) and P. Nanda Kishore as refundable and non-refundable deposit to the tune of Rs. 10,00,000/-(Rupees Ten Lakhs Only). At this juncture it is agreed between the parties that the second party would further pay a sum of Rs.67,00,000/-(Rupees Sixty Seven Lakhs Only) to the first parties as full and final settlement, for differences in area. The second party has agreed to pay the first party and their agreed associates as a full and final settlement in Two Tranches. The first tranches is paid on 16.01.2024 and the second tranches is paid on 16.02.2024, the schedule amount details of payment are as under.

1.

Puttasome Nanda Kishore HUF, Rs.5,50,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.5,22,500/- (Rupees Five lakh Twenty Two Thousand & Five Hundred Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573517 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.01.2024. 2. Shubha Kishore Rs.5,50,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.5,22,500/- (Rupees Five lakh Twenty Two Thousand & Five Hundred NC: 2024:KHC:24804 Only Vide cheque bearing.no.573515 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.01.2024. 3. Lalitha Gowda Rs.5,50,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.5,22,500/- (Rupees Five lakh Twenty Two Thousand & Five Hundred Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573518 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.01.2024. 4. T.Nagaraja Rs.5,50,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.5,22,500/- (Rupees Five lakh Twenty Two Thousand & Five Hundred Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573516 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.01.2024. 5. P.Nanda Kishore Rs.8,00,000/- vide cheque bearing.no.573520 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.01.2024. 6. Puttasome Nanda Kishore HUF Rs.7,25,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.6,88,750/- (Rupees Six Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand Seven Hundred & Fifty Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573521 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.02.2024. 7. Shubha Kishore Rs.7,25,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.6,88,750/-(Rupees Six Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand Seven Hundred & Fifty Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573522 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.02.2024. 8. Lalitha Gowda Rs.7,25,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.6,88,750/- (Rupees Six Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand Seven Hundred & Fifty Only) vide cheque bearing.no.573523 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.02.2024. 9. T.Nagaraja Rs.7,25,000/- TDS 5% (under section 194H) Net amount Rs.6,88,750/- (Rupees Six Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand Seven Hundred & Fifty Only) NC: 2024:KHC:24804 vide cheque bearing.no.573524 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.02.2024. 10. Lalitha Gowda Rs.8,00,000/- cheque bearing.no.573525 drawn on Federal bank, Bengaluru, dated 16.02.2024. The First Party is at liberty to dispose his flats without any hindrance and liability to the Second party. The First Party will be the full and final owner of the flats and handover and will be able to enjoy the property without interference from the Second Party.

f. The Second Party will provide a copy of the Completion Certificate and Occupancy Certificate within 6 months from the date of signing this MOU. Time is the essence of this Agreement. Each party shall take all necessary steps to ensure that they comply with their respective obligations under this Agreement in a timely and efficient manner. The Second Party shall also remove all its movable properties and machineries from the Schedule Property to enable the First Party to take possession of the Schedule Property.

g. If there are any disputes or differences between the parties in relation to this Agreement, the same shall be referred to arbitrator as per the prevailing conditions mentioned in the joint development agreement. Arbitration shall be conducted in Bangalore in the English Language. Subsequent to all the above being complied with, both parties acknowledge and confirm that there will be no claims whatsoever in future to the schedule property.

h. It is agreed that the second party shall pay the GST amount resultant from the handing over of residential units(flats) falling under the share of the first party at the time of handing over possession. NC: 2024:KHC:24804 i. It is agreed by second party that on handing over possession of the share of apartments to First Party, the Second Party shall comply with the provisions of law in discharging the applicable GST on handing over apartments / units to the Government and issuance of tax invoice by way of declaring the transaction in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B within due date.

j. It is further agreed that that the second party shall complete the construction and handover the residential units (flats) falling under the share of the first party within 16th January 2024. k. It is agreed that the first party would withdraw the undated notice issued by the first party unconditionally and without any prejudice to the second party.

l. The first party undertakes to Co-operate in quashing/compounding of the alleged offences in CC.NO.27982/2022, by appearing before the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in Crl.P.No.11050/2022, by giving unconditional consent for quashing the criminal proceedings in the CC.NO. 27982/2022. m. It is agreed that the other owners who are party to the Joint development Agreement are not party to this MOU and this MOU is agreed on mutual

discussion and for the benefit of the both the parties and this understanding is not binding on the other owners. Since the above settlement purely personal both the parties undertakes to maintain secrecy and the first party shall not induce the other owners for any other settlement as the conditions of the Joint development Agreement and allocation agreement will prevail for other owners in the project "Hoysala Ace-II. NC: 2024:KHC:24804 SCHEDULE

North by: Land in Sy. No.75/2 South by: Land in Sy.No.65/2B East by: Land in Sy.No.67/2 and Sy.No.4 West by: Land in Sy.No.65/1 (Hoysala Ace Phase-1

IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have set their hands and seals on the day and the year first hereinabove referred to:

SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED by them.

4.

In the light of the settlement arrived at between the parties and the offences not being against the State, I deem it appropriate to accept the same and terminate the proceedings, qua the petitioner.

5.

For the aforesaid reasons, the criminal petition is disposed. The proceedings in C.C.No.27982/2022 pending on the file of the IV Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bengaluru, stand quashed. JUDGE

RU, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 113

Reproduced from the public record of the Karnataka High Court. Verify against the court's own copy before relying on it. Income tax judgments are on bharattax.net.